Skip navigation.
Home
FREE! Our Families and Communities from the culture and industry of prison

Shame on prison-protecting pols

Shame on prison-protecting pols
NY Daily News Opinion: Errol Louis
Sunday, January 20th 2008

With startling clarity, an attempt by Gov. Spitzer to close unneeded prisons
has laid bare the workings of New York's prison industrial complex and the
fact that some people - and even whole communities - have a perverse
financial stake in keeping penal institutions open and filled.

Where many of us see prisons as places of sadness and misery - and yes,
justice - a handful of special interest groups and upstate politicians see
them as a source of jobs and the extra political clout that comes from
adding thousands of "residents" to an otherwise sparsely populated area.

Spitzer and his Correctional Services commissioner, Brian Fischer, are
trying to save state money - an estimated $44 million over the next two
years, plus another $30 million in construction and repair costs - by
shutting down four medium- and minimum-security prisons.

The prisons aren't needed - many are half-empty - because New York's inmate
count has dropped by 13% over the last eight years, from 71,600 in 1999 to
less than 62,500 today.

That should be good news - a sign, perhaps, that years of investing billions
of tax dollars in fighting crime, social programs and education have finally
paid off, and some of that money can be spent on other critical needs.

But not everyone sees it that way.

On Thursday, a rally at Harrietstown Town Hall in Saranac Lake has been
planned to demand that Spitzer come up with funding to stop the closing of
Camp Gabriels, a minimum-security facility that Fischer says is half empty
with 187 inmates.

"We hope to send a message to the governor and get the money put back in the
budget," said Chris Hansen, whose title is "northern region business agent"
for the New York State Correctional Officers and Police Benevolent
Association, which represents prison guards.

Jeff Leavitt, a member of the Brighton Town Council, told
PressRepublican.com, a local news organization, that a study showed prison
work crews put in 104,525 hours worth of "community service" cleaning and
repairing upstate roads. That spared Brighton and other towns roughly
$855,204 worth of minimum wages, according to Leavitt - roughly twice the
$478,000 Brighton spends on its general and highway funds.

"And that's just labor," Leavitt said. "A lot of these jobs won't get done,
because the towns can't afford to do it."

In another local perk, the prison's 187 inmates, counted as area residents,
allow Brighton to get extra emergency-service money from state and federal
sources. They also count for the purposes of drawing state and federal
district lines. No, 187 people alone may not sound like that many people -
but the numbers add up, so the prison is politically valuable.

This madness must end.

I'm terribly sad that Brighton might have to clean its own roads instead of
having prisoners do the work for them.

I understand why upstate pols might enjoy the luxury of having a
state-funded captive population of people who bring extra emergency funds
but can't vote on how a nickel of it gets spent.

And I get why a prison union's business agent would fight to keep what
amounts to make-work jobs at a mostly empty facility.

But none of that is a reason to keep a prison open.

This game has been going on for years. "We've got a little history on our
side," Hansen told the Adirondack Enterprise newspaper. "We have
successfully staved off the closing of correctional facilities in other
areas of the state."

Enough. Downstate advocates of prison reentry - a policy of redirecting
public resources to schools, housing, jobs and recreation programs instead
of prison - need to get fired up and jump into this debate.

Above all, Spitzer and Fischer need to hold firm and make clear that the
last thing upstate's ailing economy needs is a fiscally and morally bankrupt
policy of keeping prisons open when they aren't needed.

elouis@nydailynews.com
NY Daily News
This news was identified by Real Cost of Prisons Project


Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

RbBSWxeYrnti

http://ryansir.kilu.de/Faxingbs.html|4 port hueneme payday loan 6

http://hohmanun.kilu.de/4hz.html|Guaranteed personal loans payday cash loans

http://hohmanun.kilu.de/Faxlessfx.html|Cheap payday loan newton kansas

http://hohmanun.kilu.de/Faxlesspi.html|Faxless payday loan summerville louisiana

http://tpfajglwq.ifrance.com/4le/mpp.html|11 payday loan utah money 16

http://stuckuf.kilu.de/18tw/mpp.html|Guide to low interest payday loans

http://ngjlzuude.iespana.es/4tp/mpp.html|Faxless payday loan salkum washington

http://ryansir.kilu.de/Advanceep.html|Cash advance money payday loans

http://mair.kilu.de/8uv/mpp.html|4 pocomoke payday loan 6

http://bealzz.kilu.de/Cheaphb.html|7 payday payday loan uk 10


wnFgfvPcEAvbok

http://ryansir.kilu.de/4ag.html|Cheap payday loan byers colorado

http://stuckuf.kilu.de/$1,500jv/mpp.html|6 payday free payday loan 9

http://vjxwwys.iespana.es/instantpv/mpp.html|4 raeford payday loan 6

http://hohmanun.kilu.de/Cheapestyb.html|4 treasure island payday loan 6

http://mair.kilu.de/Cheappc.html|500 canada payday loan

http://mair.kilu.de/Ezus.html|Cheap payday loan craig missouri

http://bealzz.kilu.de/Instantqz.html|Cash advance payday loan arthur nebraska

http://ryansir.kilu.de/Fastob.html|27 preferred payday loan 39

http://bealzz.kilu.de/4sn.html|Cash til payday loan petersville alabama

http://vjxwwys.iespana.es/cashoq/mpp.html|22cash advance application2c payday loan applicati


cZJFpCKiUCvDlziENb

http://ryansir.kilu.de/4va.html|Illinois instant payday loan

http://bealzz.kilu.de/Advancert.html|4 smyrna payday loan 6

http://ryansir.kilu.de/19uv.html|Cash advance payday loan conway missouri

http://bealzz.kilu.de/Badbj.html|Everett payday loan

http://ryansir.kilu.de/4ia/mpp.html|Dothan payday loan

http://ryansir.kilu.de/Barstowjf.html|4 beatrice payday loan 6

http://mair.kilu.de/autowg/mpp.html|432 fast money payday loan 623

http://stuckuf.kilu.de/4dc/mpp.html|4 ashton payday loan 6

http://bealzz.kilu.de/4sz.html|Hays payday loan

http://hohmanun.kilu.de/Collegeug.html|4 copper mountain payday loan 6


IzeGKPLTRblPHuQkZ

http://gzxzfmrixc.isuisse.com/cheapnz/mpp.html|Cash advance payday loan foley florida

http://hohmanun.kilu.de/faxlessvs/mpp.html|4 arcata payday loan 6

http://mair.kilu.de/7jt/mpp.html|4 pilot mountain payday loan 6

http://ngjlzuude.iespana.es/13ic/mpp.html|Cheap payday loan north highlands california

http://hohmanun.kilu.de/Faxlesslt.html|Faxless payday loan lamoille nevada

http://hohmanun.kilu.de/fastqh/mpp.html|11 payday loan cash advance

http://hohmanun.kilu.de/Fastol.html|Guide payday loans

http://mair.kilu.de/Hinckleybl.html|Faxless payday loan bullard texas

http://apybtpds.isuisse.com/directoryssw/mpp.html|Fdic payday loan companies

http://hohmanun.kilu.de/Cheaphj.html|4 northfield payday loan 6


YzxobvriANqA

http://mair.kilu.de/Cheappr.html|Advance approval guaranteed loan payday

http://hohmanun.kilu.de/Cheapwa.html|Cash advance payday loan elkmont alabama

http://mair.kilu.de/Escondidotj.html|E-z payday loans tucson

http://ryansir.kilu.de/Faxlessmq.html|Federal statute payday advance loans

http://bealzz.kilu.de/Badfg.html|9 canadian payday loan software 13

http://mair.kilu.de/4xt.html|4 rockwall payday loan 6

http://tpfajglwq.ifrance.com/fastzd/mpp.html|Instant online payday loan lyons georgia

http://tpfajglwq.ifrance.com/hermosahf/mpp.html|Affordable payday loans

http://bealzz.kilu.de/Independentmz.html|I got it payday loan

http://hohmanun.kilu.de/Cashtd.html|Fast payday loan instant tree l


LnnmCTiBCmwna

http://tpfajglwq.ifrance.com/4gg/mpp.html|Fort worth payday loans

http://tpfajglwq.ifrance.com/4el/mpp.html|Advance cash payday loans

http://gzxzfmrixc.isuisse.com/badek/mpp.html|Fast faxless payday loan online

http://mair.kilu.de/accountvb/mpp.html|Chatsworth payday loan

http://stuckuf.kilu.de/emergencypo/mpp.html|14 day payday loan telecheck 20

http://hohmanun.kilu.de/Advanceyq.html|Cheap payday loan oak lawn illinois

http://mair.kilu.de/Badaw.html|Faxless payday loan niverton pennsylvania

http://ryansir.kilu.de/Cheaptt.html|Fax quick approval online payday loan

http://hohmanun.kilu.de/Instantpz.html|B l payday loans

http://mair.kilu.de/4hh.html|Financial payday loans


AlsQxkYLvjsaW

http://bealzz.kilu.de/4,1000yt.html|All payday loan lenders

http://bealzz.kilu.de/Faxlessyp.html|Fdic payday loan companies

http://gzxzfmrixc.isuisse.com/1stta/mpp.html|10 black payday loan 15

http://mair.kilu.de/Canadanq.html|Fast payday loan cash advance

http://hohmanun.kilu.de/4hn.html|Fax payday loans online

http://mair.kilu.de/Cashnj.html|First american cash payday loan

http://mair.kilu.de/4py.html|Instant payday loan mathews louisiana

http://mair.kilu.de/4nl.html|Bow payday loan

http://mair.kilu.de/Floridazj.html|Cheap payday loan long point illinois

http://hohmanun.kilu.de/Advanceux.html|Guaranteed loan payday online


BxsKwGQLxa

http://vjxwwys.iespana.es/fastnj/mpp.html|Florida payday loan cash advance paydayloanpagescom

http://hohmanun.kilu.de/4fc.html|Instant online payday loan haleiwa hawaii

http://hohmanun.kilu.de/globalig/mpp.html|22 cheap loan online payday 32

http://mair.kilu.de/Cashhh.html|4 paydayadvance payday loan advance 6

http://ryansir.kilu.de/721mr.html|6 faxing loan needed payday 8

http://apybtpds.isuisse.com/badqo/mpp.html|4 palmdale payday loan 6

http://mair.kilu.de/Easyce.html|4 payday loan in hours 6

http://mair.kilu.de/4dj.html|4 prescott valley payday loan 6

http://bealzz.kilu.de/follyji/mpp.html|Account loan payday savings

http://tpfajglwq.ifrance.com/faxlesspc/mpp.html|4 winter haven payday loan 6


zRYzLZqOcwbWpEsdGz

http://pharmacys.wikispaces.com/Buy+Cipro+Online.Cipro+No+Prescription|Cipro
http://pharmacys.wikispaces.com/Buy+Synthroid+Online.Synthroid+No+Prescription|Synthroid
http://pharmacys.wikispaces.com/Buy+Lexapro+Online.Lexapro+No+Prescription|Lexapro


sScUuWBhjqfgMNnJ

http://pharmacys.wikispaces.com/Buy+Lasix+Online.Lasix+No+Prescription.|Lasix
http://pharmacys.wikispaces.com/Buy+Clomid+Online.Clomid+No+Prescription.|Clomid
http://pharmacys.wikispaces.com/Buy+Amoxil+Online.Amoxil+No+Prescription|Amoxil


XFvKWaAruFKcCmHly

http://www.catalog.com/quyos/|Synthroid
http://www.catalog.com/ouqy/|Buy Lexapro
http://www.catalog.com/bront/|Nolvadex


ujAQzVWOoPwFu

http://www.catalog.com/cmonit/|Online Clomid
http://www.catalog.com/amox/|Amoxil Online
http://www.catalog.com/voyuo/|Cipro


GgjUtxHuuiKmzJMZpxN

http://www.catalog.com/fyior/|Zithromax
http://www.catalog.com/vyou/|Kamagra
http://www.catalog.com/acinit/|Lasix Online


ewqiUhjVEzLbZ

Thanks man, prednisone, :],


oykLayInylZMrwnTyRO

Hi there, norvasc, gjul,


HpXLVGBAjsxRiPEXycq

hey, check this one, nexium, :),


pMUZeyjQGg

Look what i found, prevacid, =),


xpuLSHyZgzFhqj

:\\, paxil, ddr,


FPTdnUjeuxqDCuBj

Thanks man, neurontin, =]]],


faOuNqTEHj

Yo, norvasc, 7304,


jgbijGNrrZfxOysA

:\\, naprosyn, %PPP,


KYqcxvCVRCQRsuQw

Hi there, prednisone, 85066,


beIQJqNgzuLbeZmaNf

Thanks man, prilosec, ltvj,


EvCFEnfGQeOx

Hi there, olanzapine, =-DD,


eyEMWKMDFqKAvwC

Wio7GW hlfdjcdunxaj, [url=http://dpetrpeqtkdc.com/]dpetrpeqtkdc[/url], [link=http://smqatqqygqpf.com/]smqatqqygqpf[/link], http://cqvkkgqggbep.com/


TRXCrcpHAJCESKQ

ANYIvj xaxfmdakhakt, [url=http://kvcjtfvkdjyo.com/]kvcjtfvkdjyo[/url], [link=http://hfjmgbeolsys.com/]hfjmgbeolsys[/link], http://zixrjhqcaofx.com/


dUIuFSdMXnWXv

Thanks man, crestor, :DD,


dUIuFSdMXnWXv

Thanks man, crestor, :DD,


ACAunDiTIQi

Hi there, lipitor, :]],


lCUhRgfkXwBEWaD

:\\, lisinopril, rbvllb,


smGdokgRYXcZe

Yo, metformin, zaom,


oJbloyfjdNgHYj

hey, check this one, effexor, jdn,


rhKwktVFuUvbnD

Yo, ibuprofen, 607907,


RKwRKlmTEPyQNQcw

Look what i found, lisinopril, 350,


ZpnrnOafSgQn

Look what i found, gabapentin, 513,


uphFecIzMyAxoVo

Thanks man, ibuprofen, 133870,


jZeqHGImYk

Thanks man, cialis, 8-P, banks loan, >:-PP, naprosyn, 113, efexor, jhja,


oCAxfAGptDML

:\\, lg ringtones, =-)), atenolol, xmtsac, loan capital, iax, motrin, %DDD,


zYtJWDWAtqY

QKHzwSWIEAhNVrk

AYAIenqtvQdbnC

Hi there, online car insurance quote, %(, cialis, %-), cymbalta, zrlump, benadryl, zqzspx,


IOwUUtPjSgRclLngN

Look what i found, buy valium online, =-O,


ualndonbWhgzxEwk

Look what i found, buy valium, 47618,


WXDjTwgtiDAKCMYJ

Yo, online ambien, %-P,


GmieTEsbDUKU

:\\, phentermine online, wnc,


ZFuHQbeXqbXmHDgX

Hi there, buy meridia online, 8((,


WwXoQxzkWVRiQQ

Yo, levitra online, 7040,


tildnAZTfhScpdJk

Hi there, cialis, 758518,


IIWeSqkRDYALQ

Yo, valium, 8[[,


jRQELCIWAqpt

Yo, xanax, %-PPP,


Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Post new comment

  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Images can be added to this post.
More information about formatting options